National Pubwatch welcomes nominations for this award. Whilst we can’t guarantee that we will make an award, we promise that we will look carefully at your nomination. The nomination process is simple but please ensure that you provide verifiable information. To make a nomination click here.
The award is named after ex Chief Superintendent Malcolm Eidmans QPM, a founder member of National Pubwatch who died prematurely in 2012. The aim of the award is to recognise the outstanding contribution made by a Police officer or member of Police Staff in supporting the work of their local Pubwatch scheme.
Lisa Elder – Cumbria Police – Reading Conference 2017
Left to right: Francis Habgood Chief Constable Thames Valley Police and Lisa Elder
Lisa is employed as a Pubwatch Coordinator for West Cumbria area by Cumbria Police for the last 10 years. The role was developed by West Cumbria Community Safety Partnership to address the rising numbers of violent crime associated with licensed premises.
She has worked tirelessly in her role to forge relationships with licensees and to ensure that their partnership information sharing agreements and protocols are sound and decisions taken to share data are proportionate and consistent.
She has taken a practical approach to many of the issues affecting local licensees and the Pubwatch scheme. For example when a number of young people under 18 years of age had been arrested in connection with incidents linked to licensed premises, the pubwatch schemes agreed to send letters to their parents informing them that the individual concerned was not welcome in the pubs and clubs and that any such repeat of their child’s anti-social behaviour would lead to a ban that would formally begin on their 18th birthday.
At every opportunity she has championed the effectiveness of Pubwatch. Her role has brought her into contact with Home Secretaries, Police Minister and even former Prime Minister David Cameron who made a special journey to West Cumbria to attend a local pubwatch meeting.
At a time of financial cutbacks the effectiveness of her role has been such that the Police and Crime Commissioner has agreed to fund Lisa’s role and two further positions in the county to ensure the partnership continues.
Phil Tibble Chair of West Cumbria Community Safety Partnership says:
The pubwatch scheme in West Cumbria has become an example of best practice in Cumbria and other areas. She is trusted by the licensees, the local councils and the police. She often has to deal directly with members of the public who have been given sanctions and she does this in a professional and personable manner. Lisa has always shown a keen interest in finding out about the latest developments and research in areas in which she works and is often used as a resource by partner agencies. Her relationships with all partners in the CSP and other agencies is excellent and she is respected by all.
Gary Slater Superintendent Cumbria Police says:
Lisa Elder has been the driving force in establishing, maintaining and developing this essential partnership in West Cumbria. Her foresight in introducing tailored information sharing agreements and robust but pragmatic policies governing the showing of photographs and the communication of pubwatch actions and decisions was instrumental in refining the schemes across West Cumbria. She personally built up the relationships needed across the widely differing communities to make pubwatch a success. Through her tireless energy, commitment and determination to bring about change, Lisa has enabled the partnership to effectively address alcohol related crime and disorder making our night time economies much safer and inviting to locals and visitors. I have no hesitation in supporting this nomination.
Sir Tony Cunningham former MP for Workington (2001-2015) Says:
Lisa has spoken to Members of Parliament, including the Home Secretary, on a number of occasions and has never missed the opportunity of ‘selling’ pubwatch and its impact to them whenever and wherever she can. I know that because of her, pubwatch was the subject that became a common theme in discussions involving Crime and Disorder and the Night Time Economy. As a Member of Parliament for Workington I was very proud of what Lisa was able to achieve through her work in reducing violent crime and disorder linked to pubs and clubs and I welcome this opportunity of supporting her nomination for the award.
Michelle Williamson – Durham Police – Reading Conference 2017
Left to right: Michelle Williamson and Michael Barton Durham Police
Michelle was unable to attend the conference and her award was accepted on her behalf by Tim Robson. Official presentation was made by Chief Constable Michael Barton Durham Police at a later date.
Michelle is a Police Community Support Officer with Durham Constabulary. In 2011 she transferred to the newly developed Alcohol Harm Reduction Unit and at that time she started to work closely with the Pubwatch schemes in Consett, Stanley and Chester Le Street.
Michelle has taken a leading role in delivering a number of harm reduction initiatives which directly impact on customer safety. In 2015 following the rape a young female in Newcastle she was one of the main promoters of a vulnerability training campaign to educate licensees and door staff of the issues surrounding intoxicated customers. The training has been delivered to literally hundreds of venues in the North East.
Later when a number students tragically lost their life in Durham City due to drowning whilst under the influence of alcohol she incorporated this issue into her presentations and delivered training, not just to university students but others on the drinking circuit.
She also worked closely with the family of Kristian Thompson who suffered appalling brain injuries and later died of his injuries, to raise awareness of the ‘One punch kills’ campaign.
She has been involved in numerous other initiatives; from tackling legal highs to counter terrorism. She even organised the Pubwatch Christmas cards which are sent out to people on the banned list!
Michelle Gill Chair of Stanley Pubwatch says:
Michelle has been an invaluable asset to Stanley Pubwatch. She never refuses to help. Her enthusiasm and strength of commitment to our members is second to none.
Alan Marshall Chair of Consett Pubwatch says:
I would just like to tell you how much we appreciate her support. She gives of her own time freely and really is the backbone of our scheme.
Sergeant Mick Urwin of Durham Alcohol Harm Reduction Unit
Michelle has been active in promoting Consett Street Friends; liaising with Pubwatch to ensure they are supported and is actively doing the same in other Pubwatch areas. She has developed and delivered vulnerability training to door staff working in conjunction with Pubwatch and the SIA. She works tirelessly to make sure there is a good working partnership between Pubwatch and Durham Constabulary.
PC Claire McNaney an Alcohol Harm Reduction Officer says:
Michelle is one of the most dedicated officers I know. Her commitment to her role in supporting Pubwatch is both inspiring and admirable; often working double shifts or staying back at the last minute; whether that be to deliver vulnerability training, promote One Punch North East or to assist with Street Friends. Michelle gave One Punch North East a great deal of time and effort, in reaching out to local Pubwatches and encouraging them to promote the cause in their premises. Michelle is a well-liked, highly regarded officer who I am proud to work with.
Inspector Nick Semper, West Mercia Police
Nick Semper has been nominated for this award by Dan Guerche Chairman of the Hereford Pubwatch Scheme.
Inspector Nick Semper and Chief Constable David Crompton
Nick has been a Police officer for 29 years and is currently a Police Inspector for Hereford City Centre. One of his responsibilities is to deal with the licensing issues relating to a diverse range of pubs, clubs and off-licences. He has been praised for his efforts to promote and support the work of the local Pubwatch scheme.
Dan says: “Nick really understands the licensed trade and the difficulties involved in running pubs and clubs. It is his understanding of the trade and realisation that pubs and clubs don’t commit the crimes themselves but are just trying to run a business and in fact suffer crime committed against the venues, customers and staff”.
‘During the years I have known Nick, in my capacity as Pubwatch Chairman; he has been supportive in my endeavours and was brave enough to pilot an ‘alcohol awareness referral scheme’ for persons who might otherwise be excluded from entering licensed premises. With his help and guidance the scheme has proved a great success in the City and has attracted a great deal of interest across the country’.
He has also taken the lead for bringing the street pastors to Hereford, but not just any old street pastor’s – he has taken the principles of Christian good will and injected a good shot of Whiskey to them! Due to Nicks hard work Hereford Street pastors have a tailor made venue to look after the lost souls of Herefords Night Time economy which has its own triage area. One of the first of its kind in the UK where our A&E department will actually send minor injuries to the Street Pastors to look after!
Nick has also worked hard on the “Safe Here” project where some venues in the Night Time Economy are now refuge spots for people who may be in distress and need basic assistance.
He has also taken the lead on Operation Castlemain – which focused on day time street drinker’s, alcohol related Anti Social Behaviour, aggressive begging as well as the life threatening situations faced by some of these people. He was instrumental in changing the way Hereford looked after vulnerable alcoholics in the day time.
Dan says that: “As a Nightclub Manager of 20 years he finds Nick to be the most forward thinking and inspirational Police officer he has ever worked with; whose dynamic thinking and problem solving initiatives are a constant and pleasant surprise”.
His nomination was supported by Paul Neades General Manager of Yates Hereford who said: “Nick has been instrumental in driving new ideas within the city and has taken partnership working to the next level. His enthusiasm has created bonds across the city which has helped Hereford prepare for growth in a safe and secure environment”
Andy Walsh a local door supervisor said: “A man whose vision and enthusiasm for a better and safer night time economy has inspired and given confidence to those that work alongside him to achieve the same goal. He always has time to answer questions, give guidance and advice”.
And lastly Steve Scully the Street Pastor Coordinator said “Working in consultation with many partners in the Night Time Economy Nick’s impact in making Hereford a safe place to be has been huge. Holistic in approach Nick was instrumental on bringing Street Pastors to Hereford and has been unwavering in his support over the last three years. Nick is an Inspector who is able to visualise and deliver the bigger picture to the benefit of all.
Trevor is a former Thames Valley Police Officer, having served for many years in the Criminal Investigation Department. For the last 16 years he has been employed as a Licensing Officer for the Aylesbury and Chiltern Police Areas of Thames Valley.
(Suzette Davenport, Chief Constable of Gloucestershire & Trevor Hooper)
He has been nominated by colleague Diane Brown a Watch Schemes and Community Messaging Coordinator. She states that throughout his time as Licensing Officer he has given unlimited support and guidance to the local Pubwatch Schemes, particularly the Aylesbury Watch whilst maintaining a professional impartiality. Aylesbury is a long running scheme established in 1995 which has been a finalist and award winner in national licensing awards run by the Publicans Morning Advertiser and received a Highly Commended in the 2013 Diageo National Pubwatch Awards. The scheme greatly assisted the town’s successful application for Purple Flag status.
He works closely with licensees, council and police colleagues, enabling a joined up approach to problem solving and issues affecting the night time economy. For example in recent years he has worked with the local Police Neighbourhood Team in the running of drug dog operations in the town centre; securing valuable funding and gaining licensee agreement and support for the operational deployment of the dogs. In a similar manner he has also been instrumental in the organisation of knife arch operations and the use of a drug ‘itemizer’ machine.
In partnership with Pubwatch members and neighbourhood officers he coordinated an operation to tackle underage drinking and the use of false ID. This included presentations to local schools and college, radio advertising, posters and procedures to deal with fraudulent /misused ID which had been seized by door staff.
He was instrumental in the setting up of a new digital radio scheme, liaising closely with the radio providers and the town’s business crime scheme to ensure a cost effective and seamless transition from the old radio link. He secured funding for the first year of the radio rental for Pubwatch members from a community safety fund.
Aylesbury Town Neighbourhood Inspector Kelly Glister says “I wish to add my personal support for this nomination. The activities of the Aylesbury Pubwatch scheme contributes greatly to maintaining the low level of crime and ASB we suffer in the night time economy. I have no doubt that Trevor’s support for their activities is a significant factor in their success and longevity. At a time of reduced funding, the work of voluntary partnerships such as Pubwatch is a crucial element in how we maintain a safe town centre and I believe that Trevor’s work in supporting the scheme over many years should be acknowledged”.
Peter Seal Licensing Services Manager for Aylesbury Vale District Council says “I’ve worked closely with Trevor for 14 years and have always been impressed by his tireless enthusiasm to improve the night time economy year on year. His proactive support for the local Pubwatch scheme and its efforts to reduce alcohol related anti-social behaviour has been one of the mainstays and most successful of the towns crime reduction partnership work over many years. Without Trevor’s professional approach the District Councils efforts to make the town a safer and more pleasant environment would not have been so successful.
Sergeant Richard (Dusty) Higgin has been the liaison officer involved with Carlisle City Pubwatch Scheme for the past 10 years. He has attended every single meeting, bar one, during this period; even when off duty and giving feely of his own time. He is extremely committed to the ethos of the scheme and works hard to encourage members to actively participate, whilst always remaining impartial.
Sir Peter Fahy Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police, Richard Higgin
At an early stage of his attendance at Pubwatch meetings he realised that there was an absence of cohesion amongst members and suggested that the scheme introduce a committee system with an elected chair person and that there should be regular meetings. This was adopted and the scheme now meets on a regular monthly basis. He was instrumental in the introduction of a computerised photograph poster system to improve the sharing of images of people banned from the scheme. He also forged links with Carlisle United to deal with the problems caused by football fans in licensed premises on match days.
He was also heavily involved in the introduction of Best Bar None in Carlisle, which is now in its sixth year and was the driving force behind the introduction of Street Pastors and Taxi Marshalls, both of which were projects that he was able to secure funding from the City Pubwatch Scheme.
Bothergate is in the centre of Carlisle and is the traditional heart of the cities nightlife scene with huge numbers of people moving between pubs and clubs at weekends. In 2008 during a peak time when many people were on the street, a pedestrian was tragically killed in Bothergate by a passing motor vehicle. This followed a number of near misses on a stretch of road that was considered to very dangerous to people using the town centre at night. Richard was instrumental in the introduction of a road closure in Bothergate, between 9 p.m. and 5 a.m. on Friday and Saturday nights. A subsequent police survey revealed that people felt that the ‘road closure’ had created more room on the street, eased tensions, reduced disorder and made them feel safer. Feedback from the Pubwatch members helped make the road closure a permanent feature
Inspector Andy Hanson Neighbourhood Policing Team says “Richard has been instrumental in the set-up and implementation of Pubwatch in Carlisle, particularly for the pubs and clubs in the City centre. The scheme has shown a positive impact on the night time economy over the past 3 years and there has been a 19% reduction in City centre alcohol related violent crime. He has encouraged licensed premises to embrace the scheme, offering help and support to those that have been unsure about its processes. The scheme is flourishing and well supported with a number of problem individuals having been banned.”
Superintendent Sean Robinson says, “Richard has made a huge difference for almost a decade through his commitment to Pubwatch in Carlisle. He has engaged and sustained partnership and cohesion within the scheme, which has made a huge difference in terms of reduction of violent crime, alcohol related crime and anti-social behaviour, which ultimately resulted in the City centre being much safer. This work cannot be underestimated in terms of supporting regeneration in a vibrant city centre in the current economic climate. He has also played a big part in supporting schemes and colleagues in other areas; in particular Eden. Richard’s commitment dedication, passion and professionalism, is a real credit to both himself and Cumbria Constabulary”.
Mike Vose the Chair of Carlisle City Pubwatch says “I have been involved with Carlisle Pubwatch for over 10 years and remember when Sergeant Dusty Higgins started attending the Committee meetings. Right from the off you could tell he would listen and absorb information and had a wonderful calm persona. Over the years he has been the voice of reason, and has never failed to help when we have asked for advice. His professionalism, his readiness to listen, and his smile have earned him the respect of the licensed trade City wide and I think it would be fair to say that the Carlisle Pubwatch scheme would not be as effective without the help and support he gives us”.
And finally National Pubwatch Regional Representative Joe Murray says “This award is a tribute to the memory of Malcolm Eidmans QPM, a man who dedicated many years of his life working for the Pubwatch cause. Sergeant Richard Higgin is someone who I firmly believe Malcolm would wholeheartedly endorse because he has also worked tirelessly over many years to support, assist and advise the pub and hospitality trade in a busy city centre Pubwatch scheme and its surrounding areas. His commitment and enthusiasm is without question and he is a worthy recipient of the award”
Malcolm Eidmans Award – sponsored by Dadds Solicitor
David Colthup – Cheshire Constabulary
David is a former Police officer who first became involved with Pubwatch whilst working for Cheshire Constabulary as a Community Safety Officer in the Congleton and Vale Royal areas.
(L-R DCC David Thompson, David Colthup and Sue Eidmans).
Not long after taking up his role he became aware of concerns raised by the Race Equality Council in relation to the banning of a member of the travelling community. In response to their concerns he helped to produce a comprehensive pack for the local Pubwatch scheme which detailed sample minutes, a banning guidance template and standardised warning, banning and appeals letters and procedures. The package met with approval from the Race Equality Council and is now used extensively across Cheshire and beyond.
For several years he has attended local Pubwatch groups to give presentations on drugs issues and he has also delivered BIIAB National Certificate Training in substance abuse at Cheshire College. With Pubwatch in mind he developed Acceptable Behaviour and Drug Safe retention policies for clubs in Vale Royal. The policies included guidance on the employment of trained and accredited staff, a transparent search and admissions policy in relation to the possession of drugs and offensive weapons and a care plan to ensure the safety and welfare of customers.
Dave is currently the Police Licensing Intelligence Officer in West Cheshire and in this role he acts as their gatekeeper for the release of photographs to several Pubwatch schemes. He regularly updates schemes with current crime trends and suspect individuals. His prompt circulations have helped Pubwatch members avoid falling victim to commonly used scams and the recent surge in the theft of mobile phones.
He can be relied upon to produce a poster or leaflet or idea for any particular issue. ‘The Don’t Scam or You’ll Get a Ban’ for fruit machines was perhaps one of his least catchy efforts, although his ‘Don’t Pay as it Goes’ for a mobile phone initiative runs it a close second!
Chief Superintendent Phil Jones of Cheshire Constabulary says “From our perspective Pubwatch is a key partner in improving public safety in the area, particularly the night time economy. It’s one of the best examples of Partnership working in action and is making a real difference to our communities.
But like most partnerships it’s the individuals who make a real difference. Dave has been a central player in developing the support and trust across the partnership which has made a real impact on local crime and disorder. On a regular basis he goes beyond what is expected of him in his role. We have seen a significant decline in violent crime and the public disorder associated with licensed premises and whilst there are many factors at play I believe that the work of Dave and Pubwatch is central to the success.
I am absolutely delighted that Dave has won this award and I endorse everything that is said about him. He is reliable and quietly efficient, he just gets on with the job of making the area safer for the community and the work he does fully deserves local and national recognition”.